What Is Imitation Crab Meat, Exactly?
You might not even know that it's not real crab meat inside your California roll
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.
Imitation crab: It’s pretty upfront about the fact that it’s not the real thing. What seems unclear, though, is what exactly imitation crab meat is made of. So, what is imitation crab, exactly?
What is imitation crab?
While it may seem like fake, processed food, indicative of modern cuisine, the roots of imitation crab go back hundreds of years to a substance called surimi. Surimi is a paste made from minced and washed mild white fish—typically pollock, but sometimes cod or tilapia—with additives to extend its shelf life. The main ingredient is usually Alaskan pollock or another type of white fish.
Japanese chefs originally created surimi to make use of extra or leftover fish fillets. It has been considered a delicacy for more than 900 years, and it’s still used in many popular Asian dishes, such as fish cakes. Chefs eventually stabilized the recipe and introduced it to other countries in the 1970s and ’80s, when it gained popularity in the United States as the foundational ingredient for imitation crab.
You’ll find surimi products clearly labeled as imitation or as a “processed seafood” or “fish protein,” per FDA policies. When dining out, be sure to ask waiters or other service staff if you’re getting the real deal or not. While it’s not the fresh, unprocessed original and will never taste exactly like real crab, many diners find that imitation crab is a satisfying, versatile and low-cost alternative.
Here are a few foods and dishes you’ll likely find imitation crab in today:
- Sushi (such as California roll, spicy crab roll, cream cheese and crab roll)
- Crab salad
- Crab rangoon
- Crab sticks
- Seafood macaroni salad
- Seafood enchiladas
- Imitation crab cakes
- Crab Alfredo
Don’t miss these other facts you didn’t know about the origin of your favorite foods.
What is imitation crab made of?
Imitation crab isn’t just surimi, so what is it made of that’s not natural fish? To achieve that unique crab flavor and consistency, food manufacturers now use additives that often include:
- Egg whites
- Natural or artificial flavors
The substance is then molded and cut into chunks or strips that mimic real crab. It may also include MSG, says Amy Leigh Mercree, a holistic health expert and bestselling author. “MSG, or Monosodium glutamate, is sometimes labeled as ‘natural flavors,'” she says. “Some people have an intolerance to MSG that induces headaches, nausea or dizziness.” She warns that people who experience this may want to avoid imitation crab.
What is the difference between imitation crab and real crab?
The difference between imitation crab and real crab is, well … pretty simple: One is real crab meat, and the other is not.
The biggest draw of imitation crab is the difference in price—it’s usually about one-third of the price of real crab meat. At-home cooks and restaurant-goers alike enjoy it in dishes like sushi or seafood salads, but nutritionally, you do get what you pay for. Although imitation crab is low in both fat and calories, Mercree says that real crab has much more protein, fewer carbs and less sodium and sugar than the imitation.
“It also lacks many of the nutritional benefits found in real crab, including trace minerals, zinc, selenium and B vitamins,” Mercree said. “Nutritionally speaking, crab is a better option.” Here are more facts about seafood that will change the way you eat fish.
Can vegetarians eat imitation crab?
While strict vegetarians and vegans should steer clear of imitation crab because it contains fish, pescatarians are free to go for it.
Diners should also keep in mind that “crabstick” or “krab,” as imitation crab is sometimes called, is a much more highly processed food and is not vegan or gluten-free unless specifically marked as such.
Is eating imitation crab good for you?
While imitation crab isn’t as nutritionally valuable as real crab meat, it is low in calories and fat, making it relatively good for you (or at least not bad for you).
How do you use imitation crab?
Imitation crab is precooked, so it’s easy to use, either chopped up or whole, in any dish of your choice, such as a crab salad or homemade California rolls with avocado. You can add it directly from the packaging to a cold dish, or heat it up to your liking.
- Thrillist: “The One Ingredient Secretly in a Ton of the Seafood You Eat”
- HuffPost: “Imitation Crab Isn’t Crab At All. So What Exactly Is It?”
- Amy Leigh Mercree, holistic health expert and bestselling author of The Mood Book
- Oregon State University: “Welcome to Surimi School”
- FDA: CPG Sec. 540.700 Processed and/or Blended Seafood Products